HomeMy WebLinkAboutCounty Council November 16 1989WHATCOM COUNTY COUNCIL
Thursday, November 16, 1989
The meeting was called to order at 7 p.m. by Council Vice Chairman Dan Warner.
Other Council Members Present: Absent:
Will Roehl Don Hansey
Corky Johnson
Tom Burton
Mary Vanderpol
Emily Jackson
EXECUTIVE ITEMS
1. APPROVAL OF BIDDERS' LIST TO ASSURE A CONVENIENT AND
READILY AVAILABLE SOURCE AND SUPPLY OF ASPHALTIC
MIXES AT THE LOWEST COST FOR ROAD PROJECTS THROUGH-
OUT THE COMING YEAR
Warner reported that Finance recommended approval of this item.
WARNER MOVED THAT THE ITEM BE APPROVED.
Motion approved.
2. APPROVAL OF BIDDERS' LIST FOR A CONVENIENT AND
READILY AVAILABLE SOURCE AND SUPPLY OF RIPRAP ROCK
AT THE LOWEST COST FOR ROAD PROJECTS THROUGHOUT
THE COMING YEAR
Warner reported that Finance recommend approval of this item.
WARNER MOVED THAT THE ITEM BE APPROVED.
Motion approved.
3. BID AWARD RECOMMENDATION FOR THE COUNTY COUNCIL
CHAMBERS SOUND SYSTEM TO PIONEER SOUND SERVICE CO.
IN THE AMOUNT OF $12,108.23, INCLUDING TAXES
Warner reported that Finance recommend approval of this item.
WARNER MOVED THAT THE ITEM BE APPROVED.
Motion approved.
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 2
4. APPROVAL OF CONTRACT WITH SHARON ROBINSON FOR
MONITORING AND AUDITING SERVICES FOR MENTAL HEALTH
AND SUBSTANCE ABUSE SERVICES IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO
EXCEED $15,000
Warner reported that Finance recommended approval of this item.
WARNER MOVED THAT THE ITEM BE APPROVED.
Motion approved.
5. APPROVAL OF AN INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT FOR MICROFILM
SERVICES WITH SKAGIT COUNTY FOR MICROFILMING THE
AUDITOR'S RECORDS
Van Zanten explained that this will microfilm most of the remainder of the
backlog in the Auditor's office.
Warner reported that Finance recommended approval of this item.
WARNER MOVED THAT THE ITEM BE APPROVED.
Motion carried.
6. NEW APPLICATION FOR A CLASS E,F LIQUOR LICENSE BY
ERNEST HUI, W. JAMES WHYTE, AND KLANE K. HUI FOR THE
POINT ROBERTS MARINA RESORT, 713 SIMUNDSON DRIVE,
POINT ROBERTS, WA 98281
Johnson reported that Public Service recommend approval of this item.
JOHNSON MOVED THAT THE ITEM BE APPROVED.
Motion approved.
7. NEW APPOINTMENT OF GARY CRAWFORD TO THE COUNTY
BOARD OF APPEALS TO FILL THE VACANCY CREATED BY THE
RESIGNATION OF JAMES KELLEY WHOSE TERM RUNS UNTIL
12/31/89. THE APPOINTMENT IS REQUESTED TO BE EFFECTIVE
IMMEDIATELY AND TO ENCOMPASS AN ADDITIONAL COMPLETE
FULL TERM TO ULTIMATELY RUN FROM 1/1/90 TO 12/31/92
Johnson reported that Public Service recommend approval of this item.
JOHNSON MOVED THAT THE ITEM BE APPROVED.
Motion approved.
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 3
8. NEW APPOINTMENT OF TIM CARPENTER TO THE SUBSTANCE
ABUSE ADVISORY BOARD TO FILL THE VACANCY CREATED BY
THE RESIGNATION OF TOM WILLERT WHOSE TERM RUNS
UNTIL 12/31/89. THE APPOINTMENT IS REQUESTED TO BE
EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY AND TO ENCOMPASS AN ADDITION-
AL COMPLETE FULL TERM TO ULTIMATELY RUN FROM 1/1/90
TO 12/31/92
Johnson reported that Public Service recommend approval of this item.
JOHNSON MOVED THAT THE ITEM BE APPROVED.
Motion approved.
9. EXECUTIVE'S REPORT
Van Zanten discussed the flood and stated the river was at flood stage at Deming
from Thursday to Saturday. Flood stage at Deming is 12 feet and it went as high as
15.28 feet. Early Thursday, Van Zanten made an emergency declaration at the request
of Emergency Services and the Public Works department; this allows County departments
to enter into contracts and get on with the business of fighting the flood. Both a Public
Works vehicle and a State Patrol vehicle had to be rescued. There was tremendous help
and support shown by community members. Damage assessments have not been
completed for County Roads but preliminary estimates of damage to State Highways
(including the temporary span at Nugent's Corner) is $1.6 Million. The County will be
asking the Governor to declare this a disaster area and she hoped there would be some
Federal Emergency Money (FEMA). It was fortunate there was no loss of life and no
serious injury.
The Solid Waste people are completing plans for closure of Point Roberts and Y
Road landfill; that deadline is the 28th of November. The are also working on an
operational plan for Cedarville which also must be completed by November 28th. The
new hours at Cedarville are 8 am to 3 pm.
Van Zanten handed out the Buildings and Codes activity report and commended
them on the tremendous workload they are coping with.
OPEN SESSION
Edna Corrick
Sand Road
She stated that the recent heavy rains were an example of what happens in the Stewart
Mountain area. The water was cascading out of the mountains and the water at the
bottom of the ravine measured 13 inches. This reinforces the residents stand that this
is just not an appropriate site. Why not drop Stewart Mountain now as a site and save
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 4
a great deal of money doing further study; there is an opportunity to save between
$125,000 and $200,000 in doing a study on this totally inappropriate site.
Bernie Higard
6160 Everson Goshen Road
RE: Proposed Muenscher Landfill
The Henmmi Road Coalition is disgusted with the issuance of this permit. The
appearance of fairness was absent. There is a growing concern in this organization over
the apparent oversight of each local department which has jurisdiction in the permit
process. Many of the laws governing this type of investigation into the facts; we'd like
to point out some of the oversights: 1. Site plan proposed site will not be visible from
the nearby; in fact it can be seen from the Everson Goshen Road, the Central Road and
the Hemmi Road; 2. The Hearing Examiner failed to consider the economic loss to
neighboring properties. Typical losses can be expensive since a water well cannot be
located within 1000 feet of this site according to WAC 173.160.205 para 2. Each
landowner can expect to have their land values drop by half; an economic study was
not done. Your decision may not have been wrong but the information that your
decision was based lacked specifics or the proper information from local governing
agencies was not available. The last step in the permitting process rests with the
Whatcom County Health Department. There will be a public hearing in front of the
Health Board Advisory Committee, and the facts will be presented within 10 ten days
to the Health Officer. If you do not forward a report, he may issue a permit without
it. He asks that the Health Board take an active roll in this process.
Barbara Brenner
5617 Northwest Road
She said she supports the withdrawal of the Stewart Mountain landfill site. On the
Muenscher site, she said she would like to see an environmental impact statement should
be done.
She had a question for Randall Watts regarding the status of the medical waste
ordinance that was passed many months ago. She stated that Don Hansey said the
reason it was passed was to get it into court quicker. Warner said he had heard on
the radio that TRC might be sold to a company who would not be interested in burning
medical waste so the question would become moot. He asked that if Randy was in the
back room to please answer this question. Brenner stated that she had spent time with
Browning Ferris Industries and has a handout from them stating that this would
undermine the Canadian environmental policy and it would invite retaliation from other
areas. She said that any policies in this regard that have been upheld have been able
to prove that there was an environmental impact to the community. She read a
statement from the Greater Vancouver Sewage District that BFI had said that they had
a facility in California that was permitted and could accept any of their medical waste
if it is not allowed in Bellingham.
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 5
Charles Amsell
Everson Goshen Road
Would like to know how to change the zoning to prohibit landfills being sited in
residential areas (R2, R5 and R10). He said he believes that the proliferation of
landfills in the County is not in the best interest of the residents.
Sylvia Schoenberg
2044 Cliffside Drive
Point Roberts
Ms. Schoenberg read letters from John and Ann Medbury and Marie Bruns in support
of the gas moratorium being extended until the Comprehensive Plan is in place. She
mentioned the 200 gallon gas spill that had occurred on October 27th. Schoenberg
thanked the County employees for the hard work that is being done on the Point
Roberts Comprehensive Plan and other Point Roberts issues. She urged the Council to
seriously consider the moratorium on gas stations be extended until the plan is in place.
Helen Cunningham
2440 Cedar Point
Point Roberts
She said she and her husband urge the Council to pass the extended moratorium on gas
stations and the newly proposed moratorium on other construction. Point Roberts is
turning into a battle zone. She said she felt the Whatcom County Planners are excellent
and we need no outside professionals.
Roehl said he was interested in the Medical Waste lawsuit and would be interested in
the status. He said that the flood has caused a slowdown in the Landfill Siting process.
Jackson asked if it would be a good idea for the whole Health Board to be presentin
the forthcoming hearings on the Muenscher landfill.
Roehl asked that a letter be sent to the Prosecutor for an update on the medical waste
lawsuit.
Jackson will ask Burton to put on an Planning and Development agenda the issue
brought up by Mr. Amsell about putting a zoning restriction on the areas that can be
used for landfills.
HEARINGS AND FINAL CONSIDERATION
1. FINANCE COMMITTEE'S RECOMMENDED CHANGES TO THE 1990
BUDGET PROPOSED BY THE EXECUTIVE (INFORMATION WILL
BE PRESENTED 11/9, AFTER AGENDA DEADLINE; RECOM-
MENDATIONS WILL BE REVISED AGAIN AND AVAILABLE FOR
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 6
PUBLIC INSPECTION LATE IN THE DAY, 11/13)
Warner explained the process that the Finance Committee had gone through and
said they had not made too many changes from the Executive's original proposed budget.
He opened the public hearing.
Shirley Forslof
Auditor
Thanked the Finance Committee for their work but did want to make another
comment on the elected official's salaries. In the exempt salary resolution she stated
that the chief jailer was being paid just slightly less than she is being paid. She has no
quarrel with what he is being paid but thinks he has several people above him. As the
County Auditor she has four department under her and she feels the extra responsibility
is worth more than $131 more per month for the added responsibility she has. She
would prefer the proposal of the County Executive or the one by the Elected Officials.
The only advocate the elected official has for a raise is the Council.
Warner said the Committee had asked the Administration and the elected officials
to bring forward a plan for elected officials salaries. The committee adopted the plan
recommended by the elected officials with one change. They added in the salaries of
Whatcom County with the other Class I and II Counties; this does bring the salaries
down because Whatcom County salaries are lower than the average. He commented on
the committee's efforts to bring equity to the salaries.
Tom Westergreen
4800 South Pass Road
Here as part of a task force concerned with woods safety and wants to encourage the
Council to provide a person to enforce safety. There have been deliberate instances of
premeditated sabotage of equipment and spiking of trees. More of the woods work is
done closer to busier areas of the County now that second growth timber is being
harvested.
Growth has put a strain on the forested areas because a lot of outdoor recreation is in
the woods. We need someone who knows the wooded area and understand forestry
related problems.
Jane Lowry
3016 Cottonwood
Representing Women's Care Center. She wished to express her gratitude to the
Executive and the Council for their support of the victims of domestic violence in
Whatcom County.
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 7
Steve Hubbard
2634 East Crestline Drive
President of Hubbard Ambulance in Bellingham. Whatcom Medic One has provided a
great service to this community. Hubbard backs up the 911 system. Over the last two
years Hubbard's activities have changed dramatically and they now operate 24 hour
service seven days a week. He is requesting that Council consider using Private Service
when they are closest ... they do have units in the Fountain area and one in Lynden Birch
Bay Road. It would take a 911 unit 15 minutes to get to the location where they would
be starting and that is a long time for a Blaine resident to wait if he is in critical
condition. Hubbard does contract work for Council on Aging on the brokerage plan.
Patricia Sabin
Bellingham Whatcom County Visitor and Convention Bureau
Thanked the Council for their consideration but they do need more. She explained the
services they provide and said that more funding would create goodwill to visitors and
get travellers to stay longer, spend more, return and encourage others to visit.
They would like to have kiosk and would need staff to man them and money for
handouts.
Warner said they had asked for $16,000 more but the committee had decided they could
not go any higher; they did put $2,500 in a fund that agencies could bid on.
Jackson stated that Whatcom Transportation Authority is adding a kiosk in Bellis Fair
and perhaps they could team up with them to cut the costs.
JACKSON MOVED THAT THE ADMINISTRATION BE ASKED FOR A STATE-
MENT OF ANTICIPATED EXPENDITURES FOR THE REMAINDER OF 1989 AND
FOR 1990 FOR THE STEWART MOUNTAIN SITE.
Warner said at this time we must treat all sites equally but Jackson said it does state
that two or three sites will be investigated. Vanderpol said he would vote against
singling one out.
WARNER AMENDED THE MOTION TO ASK FOR AN ANALYSIS FOR EACH OF
THE THREE SITES.
Motion carried unanimously.
FINAL CONSIDERATION OF RESOLUTIONS AND ORDINANCES
1. RESOLUTION ADOPTING A SALARY SCHEDULE FOR UN-
REPRESENTED COUNTY EMPLOYEES FOR 1990
WARNER MOVED COUNCIL APPROVE THIS RESOLUTION.
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 8
Jackson said she would like to add the words "any cost of living increase given
to the other employees."
Motion carried unanimously.
1B. EMERGENCY ORDINANCE TO IMPOSE A 60 DAY MORATORIUM
ON DEVELOPMENT PERMITS AT POINT ROBERTS
Burton said that Planning and Development recommended approval.
BURTON MOVED THAT THIS ITEM BE ADOPTED.
Roehl said he supported the ordinance because of the difficulty the County and
Point Roberts is facing and the Comprehensive Plan is not finished.
Johnson said he did vote for the original moratorium on service stations but said
there seems to be too many moratoriums.
Roehl agreed with Johnson that this is unusual but there have only been two in
ten years; he said we are not stopping building, just developments.
Burton said that Whatcom County is impacted by the great amount of money
coming into lower British Columbia from Hong Kong and the Middle East.
Roehl said there is no other place in Whatcom that have 48 pump gas stations.
JACKSON MOVED TO STRIKE THE SECOND WHEREAS IN THE
ORDINANCE
Roehl agrees the ordinance is badly written.
JACKSON MODIFIED HER MOTION TO HAVE THE SECOND
WHEREAS READ "DEVELOPMENT PRESSURES.... WATER SUPPLY
AND SUBSTANTIAL POPULATION GROWTH" AND DELETE THE
REST OF THE PARAGRAPH.
Motion carried unanimously.
Warner stated concern about the uncontrolled growth that may happen while we
wait for the plan to be finished.
Roehl said that the majority will be changing their zoning and deferring permits
for a 60 day period is not that long.
Motion failed. Warner, Roehl, Burton, Jackson - yes; Vanderpol and Johnson -
��a
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 9
2. ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING A PETTY CASH FUND FOR THE
PUBLIC HEALTH DEPARTMENT
WARNER MOVED THAT THIS ITEM BE ADOPTED.
Motion carried.
3. ORDINANCE CREATING A PART TIME MENTAL HEALTH
COMMISSIONER
Warner said that there was a long discussion in Finance Committee and the
Committee had recommended that this be for a thirty day period.
WARNER MOVED THAT THIS ITEM BE ADOPTED.
WARNER ADDED THE AMENDMENT THAT IT WOULD BE FOR
A THIRTY DAY PERIOD.
Amendment carried.
Johnson voiced concern about the proliferation of Commissioners.
Motion carried unanimously.
4. ORDINANCE REVISING THE 1989 CURRENT EXPENSE FUND,
PLANNING DEPARTMENT APPROPRIATION THEREIN
Warner reported that Finance recommended adoption of this item.
WARNER MOVED THAT THIS ITEM BE ADOPTED.
Motion carried.
5. ORDINANCE REVISING THE 1989 N.W. WASHINGTON FAIR FUND
APPROPRIATION FOR FAIR OPERATIONS
Warner reported that Finance recommended adoption of this item.
WARNER MOVED THAT THIS ITEM BE ADOPTED.
Motion carried.
6. ORDINANCE REVISING THE 1989 CURRENT EXPENSE FUND,
NON - DEPARTMENTAL APPROPRIATION THEREIN FOR HEALTH
DISTRICT ASSET DIVISION
Warner explained that this was an estimate of what might be assessed as the
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 10
City's share of the Health Department assets. If it is more there will have to be a
revised ordinance.
WARNER MOVED THAT THIS ITEM BE ADOPTED.
Motion carried.
6A. ORDINANCE AMENDING THE TEXT OF THE WHATCOM COUNTY
SHORELINE MANAGEMENT PROGRAM TO ALLOW THE LAND
APPLICATION OF WASTE WATERS USED IN PROCESSING FRUITS
AND VEGETABLES AS A CONDITIONAL USE
Burton explained the ordinance saying that the Department of Ecology had
reviewed it and approved. Burton discussed the benefits and dangers, and
stated that the Planning Committee recommended approval of this item.
BURTON MOVED THAT THIS ITEM BE ADOPTED.
Motion carried.
7. ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 20, THE OFFICIAL WHATCOM
COUNTY ZONING CODE, AND TITLE 2.2A, THE INTERIM ZONING
ORDINANCE TO REVISE THE LANDSCAPING, BUFFERING,
SCREENING AND SETBACK REQUIREMENTS
Burton said the Planning Committee had held this over.
8. ORDINANCE AMENDING THE OFFICIAL URBAN FRINGE
SUBAREA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN MAP FROM HEAVY IMPACT
INDUSTRIAL TO LIGHT INDUSTRIAL PARK AND AMENDING THE
OFFICIAL ZONING MAP FROM HEAVY IMPACT INDUSTRIAL TO
RURAL LIGHT IMPACT INDUSTRIAL FOR APPROXIMATELY 9.9
ACRES COMPRISING THE ELDRIDGE INDUSTRIAL SITES ON
MARINE DRIVE (PARBERRY REZONE)
Burton explained this ordinance and said the Planning Committee recommended
its adoption.
BURTON MOVED THAT THIS ITEM BE ADOPTED.
Motion carried.
OTHER BUSINESS
1. APPOINTMENT OF HEARING EXAMINER
This item was held over.
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 11
2. PETITION FOR A RESIDENT SHERIFF'S DEPUTY IN THE MAPLE
FALLS AREA (RECEIVED IN COUNCIL OFFICE 11/7)
The Sheriff will return in two week with a recommendation.
INTRODUCTION OF RESOLUTIONS AND ORDINANCES ( *CONSENT ITEMS)
1. RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION AND
FINANCING OF A NEW FOUR -STORY ADDITION TO THE
WHATCOM COUNTY COURTHOUSE TO PROVIDE FOR JUVENILE
DETENTION FACILITY AND COUNTY ADMINISTRATIVE OF-
FICES
Warner explained the resolution and stated that the Finance Committee
recommended its approval. A sheet was passed out from the Executive outlining the
financing options.
Jackson wants interim financing but would like to put a major levy lift before the
public particularly during this period of growth and economic boom. She would prefer
to pay as we go as much as possible so that folks down the road do not have to
shoulder this responsibility. The residents supported the Parks levy and they would
probably support a levy lift. If it was not supported we could fall back on current.
expense revenues and the public would be deciding how they want to prioritize County
government; it would freeze a certain amount of our capital normally used for law
enforcement and services to the community. I believe this community wants to pay for
our needs and not finance and pay interest on anything that is not necessary. Johnson
agrees and says that a bond repayment has to be paid first and if hard times come there
would be hard decisions have to be made about laying off deputies, etc.
Roehl supports resolution as written without going to voter to raise the levy lid.
Vanderpol says this does not preclude going to the voters if it passes. Jackson said she
wants the decisions made for the entire financing now so that the new Council members
won't have to come in and make decisions that should be made now. Roehl took
exception to the inference that he was leaving unfinished business.
Jackson said she would like to have the Executive's feelings on her preference for
eventual financing.
Motion carried unanimously.
1A. RESOLUTION COMMENDING THE CITIZEN VOLUNTEERS AND
COUNTY AND STATE EMPLOYEES AND AGENCIES FOR THEIR
OUTSTANDING PERFORMANCE IN THE RECENT FLOOD
EMERGENCY IN WHATCOM COUNTY.
WARNER MOVED THAT THIS ITEM BE APPROVED.
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 12
Motion carried.
The following items will be sent to the appropriate committees.
2. *ORDINANCE REVISING THE 1989 CURRENT EXPENSE FUND,
PUBLIC DEFENDER'S BUDGET THEREIN FOR PROFESSIONAL
SERVICES (FINANCE)
3. *ORDINANCE REVISING 1989 CURRENT EXPENSE FUND, NON -
DEPARTMENTAL APPROPRIATION THEREIN FOR PROFESSIONAL
SERVICES RELATED TO COLLECTIVE BARGAINING (FINANCE)
4. *ORDINANCE REVISING THE 1989 CURRENT EXPENSE FUND,
SUPERIOR COURT BUDGET THEREIN, FOR INDIGENT CRIMINAL
DEFENSE ATTORNEY FEES (FINANCE)
5. *ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING A MENTAL HEALTH CONSUMER/ -
ADVOCATE REVOLVING FUND (FINANCE)
6. *ORDINANCE REVISING THE 1989 COMBINED TREATMENT
SERVICES FUND FOR INCREASED GRANT -IN -AID FUNDING FOR
MENTAL HEALTH (FINANCE)
7. *ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING A SPEED LIMIT ON PART OF
NORTHWEST ROAD (PUBLIC SERVICES)
8. *ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING A SPEED LIMIT ON PART OF
DRAYTON HARBOR ROAD (PUBLIC SERVICES)
9. *ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING A WEIGHT RESTRICTION ON A
PORTION OF DRAYTON HARBOR ROAD (PUBLIC SERVICES)
10. *ORDINANCE PROVIDING FOR THE ISSUANCE AND SALE OF
LRID NO. 10 (CORDATA) BOND ANTICIPATION NOTES IN THE
AGGREGATE PRINCIPAL AMOUNT OF $1,095,000 IN ORDER TO
PROVIDE INTERIM FINANCING FOR IMPROVEMENTS WITHIN
LRID NO. 10; AND FIXING THE DATE, INTEREST RATE, MATUR-
ITY, FORM, TERMS AND COVENANTS OF SAID NOTES; AND
CONFIRMING THE SALE OF SAID NOTES (FINANCE)
11. *ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING EMERGENCY SERVICES AS A
DIVISION OF THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE (PUBLIC SERVICES)
12. *ORDINANCE ADOPTING A SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET FOR LRID
NO. 10 (CORDATA) FUND (FINANCE)
Minutes, 11/16/89, Page 13
13. *ORDINANCE REDUCING THE 1987 -88 ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR
R.I.D. NO. 8 AND AUTHORIZING REFUNDS FOR AMOUNTS
PREVIOUSLY PAID (FINANCE) ,
14. *ORDINANCE TO EXTEND THE MORATORIUM ON NEW
CONSTRUCTION EXPANSION OF GAS STATIONS AT POINT
ROBERTS
15. *ORDINANCE TO EXTEND THE MORATORIUM ON NEW
CONSTRUCTION EXPANSION OF GAS STATIONS AT POINT
ROBERTS
16. *ORDINANCE ADOPTING THE COMPREHENSIVE WATER AND
SEWER PLAN AS AN ELEMENT OF THE WHATCOM COUNTY
LAND USE PLAN FOR THE ENTIRE COUNTY
Burton said he would like to schedule a public hearing on December 14th
so this issue could be finalized before he leaves office.
REPORTS AND OTHER ITEMS FROM COUNCIL MEMBERS
There was a short discussion of the process that will be followed in hiring a
Hearing Examiner.
Meeting adjourned at 9:50 p.m.
WHATCOM COUNTY COUNCIL
ATTEST: WHATCOM COUNTY, WASHINGTON
Bar ra Maher, Council clerk
Daniel M. Warner, Vice Chairman